Pennington Citgo and The Ice Cream Shop

We asked for $40 and the tank just rose above half- we noticed some shady thing that he was doing on the side and hurried. Dishonest

Nov 22, 2024 · Rei Rivera

I just went and asked for 5 dollars regular cash. I just needed enough to get through the day until I am paid tomorrow. The receipt showed a sale of 1.57 gallons of gas, but there was no gas in my car. I turned around and came back to let them know. They were rude, told me "5 dollars is a tiny amount of gas," which I know, and said "what do you think we did? Pour it on the ground?" I left and asked for a manager, who said all the same things to me. I am furious, and won't make it back home now unless I can go somewhere else close enough to get gas. I will not be going there again. Absolutely the rudest treatment.

Feb 08, 2024 · Erica Brooks

Never had a problem with anyone here until about a year ago when a new guy started at night...IF he even comes out to pump your gas-if it's not cold or raining! He has given me $2.00 worth of gas instead of $20.00, I guess thinking I wasn't watching, left my gas cap open and dangling for me to realize as it banged against my car a mile down the road, and he has ignored me being there in my large bright white SUV on THREE separate occasions! Twice I drove away but today, after he looked at me twice from inside the store, I went in and asked if they were open -knowing full well after sitting there for 10 minutes and checking the web site that they were open for another 20 minutes (30 if you counted the time I'd already waited). And his response was that they'd be closing soon. When asked why he didn't come to pump my gas he said "Well, plus it's raining"! So, the bottom line is go here if you want to gamble on whether or not you'll even get gas, want to possibly get ripped off, or have damage to your vehicle! NEVER EVER AGAIN for me!!!

Nov 12, 2018 · Marylou Buck

Great stop for gas! Always met with a smile and leave with a “Thank you” and “have a nice day”. They engage while pumping your gas and always give my puppy extra attention if I bring her for the ride. Jersey girls don’t pump gas

Mar 17, 2018 · Susan Williams

The gas attendant who was working there on 8/3 at 3pm was literally crazy. He verbally attacked me, used profanity, called me a devil worshipper and told me to eat s*it. I was completely shocked. All I said was fill it up regular. Called the gas station number when I left to report the guy, but not confident they will do anything.

Aug 03, 2021 · Wolfgang Van Der Maur